Eisenkot Has 67 Endorsements but No Coalition Yet
67 of 120 MKs back Eisenkot to form Israel's government, but 19 are Arab-party seats Liberman rules out, so the Haredi draft law decides.
Israel's president is holding a number that looks like a landslide and behaves like a mirage. Sixty-seven of the Knesset's 120 members told Isaac Herzog this week that Gadi Eisenkot should get the first try at forming the next government. Forty-six said Benjamin Netanyahu. Seven abstained. Herzog says he will name his choice on Sunday, according to JNS, and he stressed that the raw tally alone would not decide it.
Where the Oct. 27 vote left the Knesset
Turnout reached 77.7%, up 7.1 points from 2022, according to the Central Elections Committee figures cited by The Jerusalem Post. Netanyahu's Likud won 27 seats, Eisenkot's Yashar party 21 and Naftali Bennett's B'Yachad 12. Add it up by bloc and nobody is close to the 61 needed: Netanyahu's camp holds 53, the parties opposed to him hold 48, and the Arab-led parties hold a record 19, including 11 for the Joint List, per Al Jazeera and AP.
Netanyahu and his allies spent the first week claiming the result was stolen, possibly with foreign help. That line has mostly run out of road. Israel's elections commission said its review of every fraud complaint found no evidence of irregularities that affected the outcome, Al Jazeera reported, and the attorney general refused to question elected officials without evidence. Herzog accepted the certified results on Nov. 4.
So the procedural fight is over. What remains is arithmetic, and the arithmetic is awkward.
Why 67 is not 61
Read the 67 carefully. It includes all 19 seats held by the Joint List and Ra'am on top of the 48 in Eisenkot's own bloc. The Times of Israel noted that neither the Joint List nor United Torah Judaism (UTJ) has said it would actually support an Eisenkot government, which makes the 67-to-46 figure closer to a theory than a coalition.
The Joint List was frank about its motive. Its unanimous statement said it wanted to widen the gap between the two men and cut the odds of a unity government that would keep Netanyahu in power, the Times of Israel reported. That is a blocking move, not a promise to serve. Ra'am leader Mansour Abbas, for his part, said his party backs the full disarmament of Hamas, which The Jerusalem Post identified as one of four principles Eisenkot has set as conditions for joining him.
Then there is Avigdor Liberman. His Yisrael Beytenu has ruled out any government that depends on either Arab party, the Times of Israel noted.
The takeaway: endorsements cost Arab parties nothing and take away Netanyahu's best argument that he is the only available prime minister. A confidence vote is a different transaction.
The Haredi draft law is the hinge
The most consequential non-endorsement came from UTJ. Its seven MPs declined to name either candidate and told Herzog their support for any future government would depend on legislation covering yeshiva students and military service, JNS reported. Degel HaTorah, which holds four of UTJ's seven seats, broke with Netanyahu because his coalition never passed an exemption law, according to The Times of Israel as relayed by Al Jazeera. Shas, by contrast, formally recommended Netanyahu.
Here the numbers start to work. The Jerusalem Post calculated that Eisenkot plus UTJ would hold 55 seats, leaving Netanyahu's bloc with 46. That is still short of 61, but a minority government could survive if Ra'am and the Joint List simply abstain.
The catch is Liberman. N12's Amit Segal reported Thursday that he had dropped his veto on sitting with haredi parties, and that the opposition was discussing a softer conscription law. Yisrael Beytenu denied it, telling the Post nothing had changed since his Monday briefing. JNS, meanwhile, described him as signaling compromise on the draft. Two readings of one man's position is itself informative: he is keeping the door ajar without committing.
The design of any Eisenkot government, then, is a bargain with the very ultra-Orthodox parties that were Netanyahu's loyal partners until this autumn.
Netanyahu's route, and the 2019 shadow
Netanyahu's own path is narrower than his 53 seats suggest. The Times of Israel noted his bloc may not produce 53 recommendations, since part of UTJ went its own way. He has answered by warning that bringing Arab parties into government would dismantle the country, according to Al Jazeera.
History adds a sharp irony. The Jerusalem Post recalled that in 2019 Liberman's refusal to back a compromise on a military draft law helped sink Netanyahu's attempt to form a government, setting off five elections between 2019 and 2022. Same man, same issue, now sitting on the other side of the table.
The clock is generous but not endless. Whoever receives the mandate gets 28 days, with a possible 14-day extension, and if no one succeeds Israel returns to the polls early next year, Al Jazeera reported. Herzog urged both camps to compromise, saying not every promise made in the campaign can be kept.
The takeaway: a candidate with a majority of endorsements and no majority of votes tends to be vulnerable, and Eisenkot's weakness is that he needs the haredim and the Arab parties to stay in separate rooms.
What to watch before the mandate runs out
My read: Sunday's mandate is close to a formality. The real signals come after it.
The first is Tuesday, when the Post reports the opposition will push to replace the Knesset speaker. That vote will show who actually shows up for a change of government, not just who recommended one. The second is whether UTJ's draft-law conditions get written into text that Liberman can live with. The third is whether the Joint List chooses to abstain or to sit out entirely.
Coalition arithmetic is turning into the defining political story of the week. Thailand's censure fight turned on a smaller party's price, and New Zealand's election hinges on a kingmaker polling near 6%. Israel's version is harsher because the kingmakers do not want to share a government with each other. If Eisenkot can stitch together a 55-seat bloc and live on abstentions, he will govern on borrowed time. If he cannot, the 67 will be remembered as the most expensive recommendation never converted into votes.
Written by
Dr. Anand Sharma
Deep Understanding of domestic and international policy.




