Blogerroom logoBlogerroom
Nature
Nature

Madagascar's Flying Foxes Have Shrunk 6% Since the 1980s

JB
Mr. Jitendra BhattNovember 6, 20265 min read
🌐 Language

Madagascar's Flying Foxes Have Shrunk 6% Since the 1980s

A Journal of Mammalogy study of 121 museum specimens finds Madagascar's flying fox skulls are 6% shorter since the 1980s, coinciding with commercial hunting.

TITLE:

SLUG:

madagascars-flying-foxes-have-shrunk-6-since-the-1980s

EXCERPT:

KEYWORDS:

TITLE IMAGE KEYWORDS:

Madagascar flying fox roost, fruit bat hanging tree, Pteropus rufus, museum specimen skulls, Madagascar forest canopy

REFERENCE IMAGE:

The image search was not run for this article. A royalty-free image needs to be sourced manually using the keywords above (Wikimedia Commons is a good starting point; check the licence on the file page). Avoid using Field Museum or press-release photos without permission.

INTERNAL LINKS USED:

- Bangka Slow Loris Feared Extinct Since 1937 Still Survives: https://blogerroom.com/nature/bangka-slow-loris-feared-extinct-since-1937-still-survives

CONTENT:

Two Madagascan flying fox specimens sit side by side on a metal tray at the Field Museum in Chicago. One was collected in 1948. The other, collected in 1995, is visibly smaller. Researchers who lined up skulls from 121 of these bats, spanning more than 150 years, now say the shrinkage is real, and that hunting may be part of the reason.

The study, by Emily Cornelius Ruhs and Steven Goodman of the Field Museum, appeared in the Journal of Mammalogy on Oct. 29, according to Science News.

What the skulls show

The team measured 12 features of the skull and teeth across 121 specimens of the Malagasy flying fox (Pteropus rufus), stored in nine museums in the United States and Europe. Bats collected before the 1980s had skulls about 3.6 millimetres longer on average, roughly 6%, than those collected afterwards, Science News reported.

Six per cent sounds small. For a bat with a wingspan of a metre or more, it is not the kind of change that is easy to spot by eye in the field, which helps explain why it surfaced only when museum collections were compared with recent fieldwork. Ruhs said the change was so stark at first that she suspected a mistake, according to reporting by Yahoo News.

Article image 1

Why hunting is the suspect

The timing is the main clue. According to Ruhs, the drop in size begins around 1980, which matches when hunting of flying foxes became commercial. Until the 1980s, the animals were mostly hunted on a small scale to feed a family or community. From then on, more bats were sold in markets and restaurants, Science News reported.

The logic is simple. Commercial hunters have a reason to go for the largest animals. "If you're the biggest bat in the sky, you might be the easiest target," Ruhs said in a Field Museum statement, and the biggest bat also provides the most meat. Many of the largest animals in the study were also older individuals, the Field Museum noted, so removing them may also remove older individuals from the population.

Flying foxes reproduce slowly. Ruhs told Smithsonian Magazine that taking out the largest, most sexually viable animals could have real effects on the gene pool.

What the study does not show

Here the researchers are careful, and the article should be too. Ruhs says the study shows a correlation between shrinking and commercial hunting, not proof of cause. Deforestation, climate change and shifting timing of the fruit season could all be playing a role, she said in the Field Museum release.

That matters because the alternatives are plausible. A species that feeds on fruit and nectar is exposed to any change in the forest. Under Madagascar's national legislation, these bats are also treated as vermin because they eat commercially important fruit, according to the museum. They are being pushed from two directions at once, and the specimens alone cannot separate the pressures.

Article image 2

Fewer bats as well as smaller ones

Size is not the only thing falling. Science News reported that there were an estimated 300,000 Malagasy flying foxes in Madagascar in the early 2000s, and that researchers estimate the number has dropped by two-thirds since.

Emma Stone, a conservation biologist at the University of Bath who was not an author of the study, told Science News that a shift in body size could leave the bats less able to cope with environmental, climate or disease stress. She cautioned that adaptation normally takes place over thousands of years, not decades. The finding suggests body size could be an early warning of species-wide trouble, though the authors stop short of saying it is one.

What would help

This is not a story about villains. The bats are a food source for families in parts of the island, and Ruhs says so plainly. She also argues for higher levels of protection under new national laws, particularly at breeding sites, so that populations do not collapse, per the Field Museum.

My read: the most useful part of the study is the method. Counting bats is expensive and slow. Measuring skulls that museums collected over the past century is comparatively inexpensive, and here it produced a signal that a field count would have been slow to find. It also echoes a point in our recent Nature story on the Bangka slow loris, where old records and local data revealed a species scientists had written off. Ruhs notes that other hunted fruit bats in Madagascar could be checked the same way, and that genetic work on modern populations would show how they are faring. Both are open questions that the museum data have now made worth asking.

ShareWhatsAppTwitterLinkedIn
JB

Written by

Mr. Jitendra Bhatt

Msc in Chemistry and field researcher.

Enjoyed this? Follow us:FacebookPinterest
← Back to Nature